In the early Seventies, American Jews have been, on the entire, centrist and standard. Most have been married, and most to different Jews. Their largest non secular denomination was the Conservative motion, with its bland, spacious suburban synagogues, representing the center floor between fusty custom and full-forced reform. This was a group that appeared to have settled into a snug established order, steadily assimilating within the postwar years and ascending into the center class.
Nonetheless, there have been indicators that when it got here to precise non secular follow, a youthful technology, coming of age in the course of the Nineteen Sixties, discovered this stability stultifying. The need for change might be felt effervescent from under. In 1972, the primary feminine rabbi was ordained. Two-thirds of Jews beneath 30 belonged to no synagogue in any respect. However in cities resembling Boston, New York, and Washington, D.C., teams of younger, well-educated Jews had begun informally worshiping and learning collectively, eschewing institutional supervision and their mother and father’ conformity.
At one such communal gathering, often called Havurat Shalom, simply outdoors Boston, three 20-somethings determined to supply a non secular ebook that may be not like something anybody had ever seen: a full of life, crowd-sourced compendium of dwell a Jewish life. It reimagined historical ritual by a counterculture sensibility, difficult each the traditionalists on the best, whose ideology framed Judaism as a strict, all-inclusive bundle of guidelines and expectations, and the reformists on the left, who largely rejected ritual for a much less demanding, much less distinctive non secular identification.
Printed in 1973 by the Jewish Publication Society, The Jewish Catalog grew to become a shock finest vendor and has been in print ever since—this yr, it celebrates its fiftieth anniversary. Solely JPS’s translation of the Bible has bought extra copies for the writer. The Catalog’s bright-red cowl, distinctive design, and eccentric illustrations empowered generations of Jews to experiment with new types of follow and group, changing into the final word guide for these alienated and estranged from the custom and looking for a extra significant different. At this time, when organized faith is beset by tumult and disengagement, The Catalog serves as a case research in how a grassroots effort to modernize non secular life can achieve profound and lasting methods, whilst a query stays all these years later about how sustainable its modifications truly have been.
The 320-page ebook, and its two sequels, emerged because the social unrest and political violence of the Nineteen Sixties have been giving strategy to a do-it-yourself counterculture epitomized within the publishing trade by the Complete Earth Catalog, which provided product opinions and sensible assets extolling self-sufficiency. However though The Jewish Catalog began as a Jewish model of the Complete Earth Catalog, by the point its editors, Richard Siegel, Michael Strassfeld, and Sharon Strassfeld, signed with JPS, they’d created one thing much more revolutionary.
By Richard Siegel, Michael Strassfeld, and Sharon Strassfeld
Till they started their mission, the traditional textual content describing dwell a Jewish life was written within the sixteenth century by Joseph Caro: the Shulchan Aruch, which accurately means “the set desk,” a longtime, extensively accepted code of Jewish regulation. Against this, The Jewish Catalog provided an à la carte menu, encouraging readers to create for themselves a Judaism that was versatile, casual, and proactive. Need to observe the Sabbath however the prayers and legal guidelines don’t resonate? All you need to do is bake challah as soon as per week? Effectively, right here’s a recipe or two, together with hand-drawn depictions of a number of methods to braid the ceremonial bread.
“You’ll be able to plug in wherever you need,” the editors wrote within the introduction.
Chaim Potok, by then an acclaimed novelist well-known for The Chosen, was JPS’s prime editor, and though he instantly grasped The Catalog’s potential, he confronted a tricky promote with some members of his board, who have been aghast at publishing such an untraditional, at occasions irreverent work. However he endured. “Chaim was a visionary,” Sharon Strassfeld advised me.
On the time, the Strassfelds (who have been then married) and Siegel (who died in 2018) have been members of Havurat Shalom, a lay-led group that was among the many pioneers of an egalitarian, participatory type of worship, studying, and ritual follow. The Catalog mirrored these values. “We have been writing concerning the lives we have been residing,” Sharon Strassfeld mentioned.
The editors of The Catalog explicitly critiqued typical Judaism as “prefabricated, spoon-fed, nearsighted.” They even titled one chapter “Utilizing the Jewish Institution—A Reluctant Information.”
However total, the tone and presentation have been playful, inclusive, affirming. Fuzzy pictures of barefoot women and men clasping arms and circle-dancing have been juxtaposed with an ultra-Orthodox bride and groom at their wedding ceremony; long-haired hippies have been on one web page, long-bearded Hasids on one other. In Adrianne Onderdonk Dudden’s design, the pages had a Talmudic really feel, with commentary and explanations wrapped round the primary textual content. Stu Copans’s charming line drawings have been each instructive and cheeky; so have been the editorial notes. (The recipe for cholent, a long-simmering stew, says it can feed 10 regular folks or two Hungarians.)
“I don’t assume we have been making an attempt to stay it to the person,” Michael Strassfeld advised me. “We had a really totally different means of seeing Jewish life, and this ebook was an expression of that. Organizational Jewish life was boring. Suburban Jewish life was boring. We have been making an attempt to hook up with a extra genuine previous—making an attempt to recapture one thing, not destroy the system. We wished to supply one other mannequin.”
And that mannequin exuded the carefree happiness and unconventionality of the broader youth tradition. Why do prayer shawls have to return solely in black and white? Why can’t they be multicolored? And why can’t ladies put on them too?
“It’s the notion that you are able to do this, you possibly can personal it,” Beth Wenger, a historical past professor on the College of Pennsylvania, advised me. “You don’t have to go to some establishment to do it. It’s yours. That was what was so impactful.”
Without any mass advertising to talk of, aided largely by phrase of mouth and a New York Instances story, The Catalog instantly bought out its first printing, shifting 50,000 copies in its first three months, and 130,000 copies in 18 months. (More moderen numbers should not out there, although JPS says that whole gross sales are within the many a whole bunch of 1000’s.)
For a distinct segment writer like JPS, these numbers have been unprecedented. However this recognition didn’t come with out controversy.
Most notable was a prolonged, scathing essay by Marshall Sklare, then the nation’s preeminent sociologist of Jewish communal life, within the December 1974 concern of Commentary journal. Titled “The Greening of Judaism”—this was not meant as a praise—the essay criticized the Catalog editors for exempting “themselves from the central characteristic of Jewish non secular regulation—its normativeness.”
The Catalog, Sklare summarized, “is wealthy in ironies, a piece wherein a real familiarity with Jewish sources and Jewish follow has been put on the service of the newest cultural and aesthetic predilections, with outcomes which might be humorous, vulgar, charming, and meretricious unexpectedly.”
Placing apart the lacerating, demeaning tone, Sklare pointed to a central fact: The Catalog was certainly advancing a Judaism that was centered on magnificence and that means and private expertise quite than on communal obligation and bowing to hierarchy and authority. You have been invited to behave and assume a sure means, not commanded to take action.
But when The Catalog challenged the prevailing orthodoxy of the best, it was additionally an implicit rebuke to the American Judaism of the left, notably the extremely standard Reform motion, which on the time eschewed non secular ritual and overt shows of ethnicity in favor of a extra Protestantlike ethic, with many prayers in English and providers that have been briefer and left little room for shows of prayerful emotion.
A lot of what The Catalog gave voice to 50 years in the past has migrated from the margin to the mainstream of American Judaism’s liberal denominations, and even a few of its extra conservative sectors. At this time, synagogue worship typically is much less formal and extra participatory; ritual conduct is frequently being reinvented. Egalitarianism has seeped into Trendy Orthodoxy. And, propelled by the pandemic, each different Jewish family, it appears, is making challah for Shabbat.
Extra broadly, Beth Wenger famous, The Catalog’s outlook “is attribute of American faith, which is basically a menu immediately.”
Maybe not even Marshall Sklare, have been he nonetheless alive, would dispute that The Jewish Catalog had a penetrating and lasting impression on American Judaism. However the huge ebook that gave the impression to be on everybody’s shelf is now largely a beloved historic artifact. The web gives in a millisecond what The Catalog’s authors took years to compile. Books meant to be assets are immediately outdated the second they go to press. Pages and pages of The Catalog’s finely packed chapters itemizing students and references and organizations are actually out of date.
Conventional gatekeepers of data and steering—be they rabbis or different consultants—have barely a supporting position in lots of life’s dramas. That’s largely as a result of technological advances, however it’s additionally due to the diminished significance of non secular establishments within the each day lives of American Jews and, certainly, many different People.
Whether or not The Catalog initiated that growth or catalyzed it, whether or not it shifted the route of American Judaism or gave vivid expression to a shift already within the making, it’s onerous to think about up to date American Jewish life with out the permission to experiment that this quirky, oversize ebook represented.
“Probably the most subversive factor we did, and it was utterly inadvertent, is that we have been giving folks in English instruments in order that they might construct their very own Jewish lives,” Sharon Strassfeld mentioned. “Till then, who was writing a Jewish ebook? Rabbis and students. The Catalog’s total objective is to present possession to folks of their very own Judaism.”
As a ebook, The Catalog’s origin story had all of the substances for fulfillment: idealistic and educated editors, a visionary writer, a second ripe for disruption. However to be able to actually encourage a motion to reinvent non secular life, the ebook additionally required readers with the talents, ardour, and dedication to embrace its DIY ethos. It takes numerous work to really personal one’s faith, to be answerable for its sustainability. Half a century on, The Catalog’s contributions endure, however so do the lingering challenges of constructing religion really feel related and recent in a contemporary world.
Once you purchase a ebook utilizing a hyperlink on this web page, we obtain a fee. Thanks for supporting The Atlantic.
