This text was featured in One Story to Learn At present, a publication through which our editors suggest a single must-read from The Atlantic, Monday by way of Friday. Join it right here.
Twenty-nine years in the past, Dave Grohl, then the drummer for Nirvana, misplaced his singer, the band’s sensible and vexed chief, Kurt Cobain. Final yr, Grohl, now the chief of Foo Fighters, misplaced his drummer, the dazzling Taylor Hawkins. After which, a number of months later, Grohl’s mom, Virginia, died. She was, amongst different issues, the ne plus extremely of rock mothers, a instructor by occupation whose help for her charismatic, punk-loving, unscholarly (her mild phrase) son was unfaltering and absolute.
One blow, then one other. It was all a bit a lot. Grohl is an unreasonably buoyant particular person, nevertheless it was exhausting to think about how he would pull himself out of a trough dug by such concentrated loss.
However he did. And he did so by writing his approach out.
Not lengthy after his mom died, Grohl advised me that he was writing new songs—songs, he recommended, that will handle, amongst different topics, grief and mortality. I hoped for the most effective however was anticipating one thing much less. Not that anguish and moody interiority are international to Foo Fighters—“I Ought to Have Identified” and “These Days,” from the 2011 album Losing Gentle, may very well be written solely by somebody conversant in the capriciousness of sudden loss—however mawkishness however threatened.
These worries have been useless. The newest Foo Fighters album, However Right here We Are, is a hovering, frenzied guitar assault whose songs usually recall the band’s finest stadium-shaking anthems. However extra to the purpose, it’s full of lyrics that really feel true of their sustained confrontation with the album’s principal topic: shattering absence.
Earlier than I proceed, an admission of bias: You’re studying a fan’s notes, not an album overview, so low cost accordingly. Grohl has written for this journal, and he and I are associates, although my love for his music predates our friendship by many years. His songs have made me glad since Scream, his first band, which he joined in 1986. Grohl’s dependable dedication to exuberant drums-and-distortion-pedal noise makes him a hero to these of us who’re ready—in useless, almost certainly—for the triumphal return of rock. Foo Fighters exhibits are joyous communal gatherings—due to the music, after all, but in addition as a result of Grohl is a self-aware rock star with superior comedian timing. He’s additionally unusually gracious to the very massive quantity of people that lose their minds in his presence, together with the middle-aged fellow who lately approached him in a restaurant, hoping to point out him his Dave Grohl tribute tattoo. The tattoo was apparently positioned in some unspeakable place, and Grohl deftly and kindly steered the fan away from stripping.
One other acknowledgment: Grohl and I’ve spoken fairly a bit about this album, however I’m respecting his need, and that of the band, to let the music communicate for itself. They’ve achieved no press across the album, a call I perceive personally, if not professionally.
This album, nonetheless, explains itself, even throughout its extra elliptical songs. The ferocious title monitor, a real Foo Fighters pile driver, makes itself understood by way of Grohl’s throat-tearing screams: “I gave you my coronary heart / However right here we’re / Saved you my coronary heart / However right here we’re.”
In some methods, However Right here We Are is paying homage to The Rising, the 2002 Springsteen masterpiece, which explored the sudden void that’s created by tragedy, although with much less thrashing. The Rising was a response to the terrorist assaults of 9/11. The unhappiness that conjured However Right here We Are into being is a extra acquainted, on a regular basis one. Hawkins, along with being one of many nice drummers of his period, was Grohl’s closest good friend. The desert created by his sudden loss of life is the area Grohl explores with deep sincerity. In “Beneath You,” Grohl sings, “Somebody stated I’ll by no means see your face once more / A part of me simply can’t consider it’s true / Footage of us sharing songs and cigarettes / That is how I’ll all the time image you.”
There are hints of darkish complication scattered throughout the album: In “Listening to Voices,” Grohl sings, apparently to Hawkins, “Each evening I inform myself / Nothing like you might final endlessly / Nobody cries such as you … / Nobody lies such as you.” This album is an act of forthright self-exposure, an unaffected testomony to the love that’s natural and integral in the most effective friendships. “I had an individual I beloved, and identical to that / I used to be left to dwell with out him,” he describes, heartbreakingly, in “The Glass.”
Disbelief on the actuality of loss of life is threaded by way of these songs. The primary monitor, “Rescued,” opens with an act of mercy for followers who’ve been ready for Grohl to deal with the lack of Hawkins: “It got here in a flash, it got here out of nowhere / It occurred so quick, after which it was over.”
However it’s Virginia Grohl’s loss that in some ways sits on the heart of this album. Opinions of However Right here We Are have been uniformly optimistic, however I’ve additionally seen some interpretative confusion among the many critics. Songs which can be clearly concerning the loss of life of Grohl’s mom are generally described as tributes to Hawkins. About some songs there isn’t a confusion. “The Trainer,” a 10-minute opus, is a tribute to Virginia, even quoting her final phrases to Grohl, who stored vigil bedside in her final days. “Hey child, what’s the plan for tomorrow? / The place will I get up? / The place will I get up?”
“The Trainer” is adopted by the album’s last monitor, “Relaxation,” a haunting music that begins with a single, mournful acoustic guitar and ends with the album’s first and solely imaginative and prescient of peace: “Waking up, had one other dream of us / Within the heat Virginia solar, there I’ll meet you.” The plea to relaxation is directed at each Hawkins and Virginia Grohl. “Virginia solar” does double responsibility right here: Grohl is a proud native of Washington, D.C.’s Virginia suburbs, and Hawkins, like the opposite Foo Fighters, was just about an adopted son of Virginia Grohl’s.
Although the brand new album ends with the acceptance of loss of life, Grohl is making a extra sophisticated argument throughout its 10 songs: With some deaths, there may be decision—generally, all the things that ought to have been stated between two folks truly will get stated. One has the sense that that is the case together with his mom. With Taylor Hawkins, there was no such decision. He died earlier than his time, abruptly, shockingly. Virginia’s loss of life was despair-inducing however nonetheless a part of the pure order. Hawkins’s, like Cobain’s earlier than his, was not. Grohl has dug himself, and his band, out of a trough, however absence, to borrow from W. S. Merwin, goes by way of him like a thread by way of a needle, stitching all the things with its shade.
However Right here We Are is the most effective Foo Fighters album in fairly a while. Tragedy isn’t needed to provide transcendent music. However right here, it did.
